2009 Harley Davidson FLSTC Heritage Softail Classic Logo
A
Anonymous Posted on Apr 02, 2014

2009 HERITAGE SOFTAIL STARTER HOT GRIND

STARTER MAKES GRINDING NOISE AND I HAVE TO TRY SEVERAL TIMES WHEN HOT AND GIVE XTRA GAS.

2 Answers

Gar

Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Vice President:

An expert whose answer got voted for 100 times.

  • Expert 384 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 03, 2015
Gar
Expert
Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Vice President:

An expert whose answer got voted for 100 times.

Joined: May 01, 2009
Answers
384
Questions
1
Helped
162265
Points
779

Starter clutch or solenoid is bad. Hard to tell from your description without hearing the bike. Croaked starter clutch will make a low volume grind, almost a buzz, but with no appreciable banging or severe mechanical noises, but the engine won't turn over. You should hear the bendix kick the starter gear in, with a solid thunk, then the buzz starts.

A dead solenoid (bad pull in or hold in coil) makes an AWFUL noise, grinding the starter gear against the clutch gear, often with the starter kicking in and out. This WILL break something if not fixed quickly.

Remote possibility your starter bendix is bent/sticking.

If you do it yourself, plan on an all day adventure. You will need a HD/Clymer/Haynes manual. But the parts should run well under $100. Someone with average mechanical ability can do this, if you follow the instructions, whether replacing the starter clutch (moderately hard) or the solenoid (easy).

Best I can do without hearing the bike.

monkeybiznez

Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Novelist:

An expert who has written 50 answers of more than 400 characters.

Scholar:

An expert who has written 20 answers of more than 400 characters.

  • Expert 136 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 03, 2015
monkeybiznez
Expert
Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Novelist:

An expert who has written 50 answers of more than 400 characters.

Scholar:

An expert who has written 20 answers of more than 400 characters.

Joined: Jul 30, 2010
Answers
136
Questions
0
Helped
51212
Points
220

That does not sound good. I suggest you get it to a dealer before you do any additional damage.

Ad

5 Related Answers

Anonymous

  • 4565 Answers
  • Posted on Sep 24, 2009

SOURCE: how to change oil for2007 heritage softail classic

The oil drain us usually a hose with a plug in it that is held by a clip on the frame. It us usually on the right hand side of the bike just behind and underneath the transmission side cover. Loosen the clamp and pull the plug out. The oil will run out of the tank. Replace plug and add new oil to the tank.

Ad

Anonymous

  • 17 Answers
  • Posted on Feb 16, 2010

SOURCE: harley davidson flstc heritage softail 1997

The fork oil is a very specific job needing a manual and a special tool, I don't want to insult anyones mechanical knowledge but if you have never done it before, best to take somewhere else. Engine oil on the other hand is easy, the drain tube to any softail is on the right side by where the frame meets the swing arm, has somekind of plug in it. Start and run bike for a little while, long enough to get it warm but not hot. Remove fill plug and then remove plug in drain line. Using a peice of cardboard or something put in between filter and frame , directing the oil to your drain pan instead of where ever it goes. Put 1 qt oil back in (after everything is reinstalled) start the bike and make sure the oil light goes out, when it does shut bike off and fill to the point that when it is standing upright you get a little oil on the tip of your finger, over filling may result in loss of oil cap from pressure (been there)

Anonymous

  • 4565 Answers
  • Posted on Jul 25, 2010

SOURCE: starter grinding

It could be any number of things but the most likely in my opinion is that you have a bad "over running clutch" or "starter clutch" in your bike. You didn't tell me what year model bike you have but the header of this post says you have a 2000 FLSTC Heritage.

The starter clutch can be replaced and you can save some money if you can do your own work. If not, the cost of repairing your starter and simply replacing the starter is about the same due to the added labor time required to take yours apart and replace the bad part. The starter clutch cost about $120 US. Once you get the starter off, there is about another hour labor to replace the clutch.

Good luck
Steve

Anonymous

  • 4565 Answers
  • Posted on Sep 26, 2010

SOURCE: diagnosing starter problems with 1993 heritage

Ok, the first thing to do it take your battery to an auto parts store and ask them to "load test" the battery. Just because you charged it doesn't mean it's any good. Especially if the battery seemed to come up to full charge very quickly.

If the battery test good and all you're getting is a click out of the starter, first check all your connections to make double sure they are clean and tight. If they are, there is a five sided plate on the end of the starter's solenoid on the right side of the bike. It has three small bolts that holds it on. Remove the bolts and remove the plate. Remove the large plunger and spring. Inside, you'll see two large copper contacts. One or both of these contacts are probably pretty well burned down. One will have an "arched" looking area in it. This is where the large washer on the plunger has made repeated contacts and has burned the contact down. It is NOT supposed to be there. The copper contacts should be smooth.

You can purchase a "rebuild" kit to replace these two contacts and the plunger. Much less expensive than purchasing a starter and much less work.

Good luck
Steve

Anonymous

  • 4565 Answers
  • Posted on Feb 08, 2011

SOURCE: how to remove starter 1995 heritage softail

To remove the starter on you Softail, first disconnect the negative side of the battery.

Then drain the primary and remove any footboards, shifters, ect. so that you can get the outer primary cover off. Once the cover is off, remove the small bolt that holds the starter jackshaft on and remove the jackshaft. The jackshaft coupling may come out with the jackshaft. Mark which way the coupling goes back in as there is a snap ring on the inside that is not in the center.

Now, go to the right side of the bike and remove the exhaust system, and remove the bolts that hold the oil in. Do not take the tank out but you need to be able to lift the tank just a bit. Remove the battery cable from the starter using a 12mm wrench. There are two large bolts that hold the starter into the inner primary, remove these two bolts and unplug the small wire at the top of the solenoid and the starter will come out.

Good Luck
Steve

Ad

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

0helpful
2answers
1helpful
1answer

2009 Heritage Softail engine won't turnover

Is the run/stop switch on the right handlebar in the "run" position?
0helpful
1answer

Need to replace starter in a 2009 harley davidson softail heritage

You will really need a service manual on this. Remove seat. Remove battery. Remove exhaust system. Drain and remove oil tank. Remove starter leads. Remove starter. Replace. Reinstall above in reverse order of disassembly.Don't forget to put oil back in.
0helpful
1answer

I have a 2000 Heritage Softail Springer. Recently the starter makes an extremely loud grinding sound intermittently when I try to start it. It doesn't do it every time but sounds really bad when it...

This could be several things....how old is your battery? if it isn't holding a full charge it sometimes won't have the cranking amps to fully engage the starter. It could be the solenoid or the starter itself but I would start with the battery.
1helpful
1answer

Starter makes grinding noise.... Can you help me? 1997 heritage softtail.

The first thing I'd check is the jackshaft and the ring gear on the outer clutch hub. Disconnect the battery. Drain and remove the outer primary. Inspect the ring gear and jackshaft looking for "roughness" on the teeth of the two gears of broken teeth. If you find any, you'll have to replace the parts.

If those parts look good, your problem is probably the "starter clutch" inside the starter. This is the one way bearing type device that allows your starter to turn the engine over but then freewheels the starter once the engine does start. This part can be replaced without having to purchase an entire starter but you'll have to disassemble the starter to replace it.

Good Luck
Steve
0helpful
1answer

Starter grinding

It could be any number of things but the most likely in my opinion is that you have a bad "over running clutch" or "starter clutch" in your bike. You didn't tell me what year model bike you have but the header of this post says you have a 2000 FLSTC Heritage.

The starter clutch can be replaced and you can save some money if you can do your own work. If not, the cost of repairing your starter and simply replacing the starter is about the same due to the added labor time required to take yours apart and replace the bad part. The starter clutch cost about $120 US. Once you get the starter off, there is about another hour labor to replace the clutch.

Good luck
Steve
0helpful
1answer

I have a paucho rigid frame and a 1980 shovelhead 1340 cc motor with kick and electric starter and i need a wiring diagram also it has a heritage softtail forks and lights and switches

The shop manual for shovels has a diagram in it .They're all the same except for xtra lights your bike probably doesn't have. Get the heritage book too for the front end wiring.Both have alt./stator/reg. so have at it.
0helpful
1answer

I have a 2005 Honda Odyssey which makes a grinding noise at high speeds when I accelerate. Computer diagnostic is clear. Every time car goes into ECO and I try to accelerate it makes this noise. If I...

Could be wheel bearings . Some times they make noise at certain speeds. Even had a vibration with a tires out of balance. I had to get new tires.
Not finding what you are looking for?

617 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Harley Davidson Experts

Arnie Burke
Arnie Burke

Level 3 Expert

7339 Answers

Sean Wright
Sean Wright

Level 3 Expert

2045 Answers

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Are you a Harley Davidson Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...